American Thrift Store - Farmingville NY 11738

P

Patricia Coome

Went there n found an expensive yellow tag dress. Actually 2 dresses. They had those security tags. I said to the girl, oh please make sure u remove them. She just kinda looked at me. I saw her remove the tag on the 2nd dress. I said, did u get the first dress security tag? She kinda looked at me. I guess i wasn't worth her energy to respond to me as a customer. When I went to walk out the door, the alarm beeped. The guy at his register right near the door checked my bag, n found a security tag on one of the dresses n he kindly removed it. I thanked him, but I did tell him it would've been quite a problem for me to drive ALL THE WAY BACK TO FARMINGVILLE AS I LIVE FAR AWAY. I also told him I had asked that cashier girl to make sure the tag was off twice! Obviously, that cashier girl really doesnt care about good customer service or being polite to the customer when asked a question n just kinda looking at you. Finally, when I got home n hung up the VERY EXPENSIVE YELLOW TAGGED DRESS,there is saw near the bottom A GIA N T CIGARETTE HOLE!!! I know it is our responsibility to examine the clothing before buying, but while your in the store, you hold it up, you turn it around, u try it on in the dressing room, abd you DONT SEE THE GIANT CIGARETTE HOLE TILL U GET HOME!!! DONT THEY LOOK AT THIS STUFF BEFORE THEY PASS UT OFF AS EXPENSIVE WITH A YELLOW TAG??!!! I feel the store doesnt care, and they just want to sell ANYTHING to make a buck! Shame on you ameruan thrift! And the owner can feel free to contact me! Terrible!!

C

Christina Tran

The store is huge and has a wide variety of items from home goods to clothing and other miscellaneous. You could spend a few hours in there and most items are reasonably priced, but there’s a “luxury” section where certain clothing cost more. There’s different discounts every day, so the deals are better for pricier items. The staff are friendly and I enjoy coming here during my free time!

J

Jesse Elliott

Overall, excellent experience! It was very organized very clean very professional operation. A diverse selection and fair prices, including the designer/luxury brand names. Large inventory and comfortable fitting room. This should be a shopping destination on any thrifter itinerary mid-Island.