Reid Brothers Inc. NY 11963

S

Sam Harper

I read some of the bad reviews on this page and can't believe they're talking about the same garage. I am NOT a Sag Harbor local. I'm visiting for a few weeks and, for various reasons, had to bring my beater Subaru in for service on axle, oil, electrical, tire sensors. They knew I was from out of town, and could tell that I knew nothing about cars which makes me a target for overcharging and doing unnecessary work. They could NOT have been nicer, they did the work in a timely fashion, charged really reasonable rates, and actually encouraged me to NOT do work that would have made them a LOT of money. Suffice to say, Reid Brothers is one of the three things I love about Sag Harbor other than the beach and the Whaling Museum.

L

Lance Wilson

I spent approximately $700 to have a faulty tire pressure warning light repaired. Reid Bros. claimed that four new tire pressure sensors were needed. The new sensors did not resolve the problem. I will not use Reid Bros. again.

C

Casey 3339

I like these guys and they are probably competent mechanics. But they just charged me $141 for an oil change for my 2017 Ford Explorer. I’m not talking about anything else other than a straight up oil change. In the past I have paid between $60-$80 elsewhere. I understand that a lot of vendors will thieve on people coming out for the summer. But I’m a local and robbing me is unacceptable. The only way any an establishment whether it be a restaurant, service station or whatever will stop gouging practices is if people stop using them. I would urge anyone and everyone to seek service anywhere else. Unless you like paying double for something.