New York Athletic Club NY 10019

S

Steve Kusik

Very nice place. Intended for upscale amenities, experience, atmosphere. We are not members but we’re there as guests for an event.

R

Raquel Gerlani

The New York Athletic Club is hands down one of my favorite members-only spots in the city. Every time I go, I feel like I’m stepping into old-school New York elegance—but in the best way. The main dining room is absolutely divine—the décor is classic and timeless, with beautiful detailing that makes the whole space feel really special. One of the things I love most? The live piano music. It adds such a sophisticated and cozy vibe, especially during dinner. Whether I’m going for a quiet meal or a special celebration, it always feels like the perfect setting. You definitely need to be a member (or go with one) to enjoy it, but if you ever get the chance—it’s 100% worth experiencing. @raquelgerlani

A

Andrew Kerr

Rude and inflexible, a review of the NYAC (this is a review of only the hotel only, I didn’t use the exercise or dining facilities): On paper, it looks like a good idea to stay here. Convenient location, views of the park, relatively spacious rooms and a reasonable price, it should be a good choice. However, a dress code that requires dress shoes and a coat for men (and similar levels of formality for women), prohibits the use of ground floor elevators to anybody staying in the hotel who would dare to wear anything more casual and try to use the ground floor elevators. The fact that the dress code effectively makes the accommodations a two story walk up if you need to wear more supportive shoes (or don’t walk around NYC in a sport coat during the heat of summer), made for a very unpleasant stay. Getting consistently harassed by hotel staff who insisted that we walk up a back staircase instead of use the elevator bank in the lobby was a nice touch.